Little Italy Pizza

2047 Broadway, New York, NY 10023 Order now
Hero image

Our reviews

Reviews from Grubhub

Little Italy Pizza Reviews on Grubhub

Nicholas

Top Reviewer
Pizza was made quick and fresh for when I arrived. People working in there were friendly and I was in and out. Pepperoni pie was very good and my kids loved it too. Would definitely recommend this place to anyone living in the area or even visiting New York

Carmen

1 review
Never had a slice that I didnt like! Food was hot and ready when picking up. Got delivered a few times and it is always fast and nice delivery men. My company orders 10+ pies twice a month and we are always very satisfied

Simon

3 reviews
Their tomato sauce is delicious. Wished i had the recipe it was sweet. I usually get acid reflux from eating tomato sauce with pasta or pizza but this one was extraordinary. Well done good job!!

Donna

1 review
I ordered the pepperoni which was high quality , the kind that cups and holds the spicy oils & crips .. the crust was delicious & cooked perfectly the way I like it . I will be back !!!

Joseph

1 review
Was immediately drawn in from the smell of the pizza from outside
Manager was extremely nice
Food was ready and hot for pick up
Best pizza on the UWS, will not go anywhere else!

Reviews from Seamless.com

Little Italy Pizza Reviews on Seamless

Angela

Top Reviewer
My order arrived about 8 minutes earlier than the app said it would; in fact, the app still said that it was in the works when the delivery guy arrived and for about 15 or so minutes after! The guy seemed a little lost looking for the door where I said I'd meet him, but we did meet. He was very courteous as he confirmed that I was the customer for whom he was looking. The food was still very hot and the bottled soda was ice cold. Everything tasted great. I would definitely order again!

Mark

3 reviews
The best grandmas pizza especially on the upper west side. The original regular pizza pie has a lot of corn meal on the bottom. Some people like it. Some dont. I dont like it because it makes a mess on the floor. They are very fast (usually under 30 minutes) and when they are very late they apologize and try to make it right. Never had a bad experience with them. When I know I want pizza delivered then this is my go to place.

Melissa

Top Reviewer
After another restaurant messed up my order, I was starving and in need of something satisfying and quick. Luckily, the order came quickly, the delivery man was friendly, and while perhaps some of the slices werent the freshest, I got two meals worth of food that hit the spot and improved my day.

Heather

Top Reviewer
Ordered a cheese pizza at 4:55 and was it was delivered hot and arrived 15 minutes earlier than expected at 5:20. Very satisfied! We always order from here.
The only time a delivery was late and the food cold was Halloween but honestly, that's to be expected on such a busy night.

James

Top Reviewer
We enjoy the pizza here. Tasty sauce. We like the Fresh Mozzarella and Grandma's Pizza. We always order whole pies so the pizza is fresh and delicious. The crust has lots of corn starch flakes on the bottom, this gives it a crunchy texture that we like, though it can be messy.

About us

Calzones, Italian, Pizza, Salads
Today
Delivery: 10:00 AM - 5:00 AM
Takeout: 10:00 AM - 5:00 AM